Back to blog
·4 min read

Talent review: how to assess potential and decide where to invest

A performance review looks back: what the person did this year. A talent review looks forward: how far they can grow, what they need and what the company does about it. It is the meeting where you decide who to invest in, who the successors for key roles are and who needs looking after so they do not leave.

Done well, it is one of leadership’s most useful conversations of the year. Done badly, it is a session of opinions won by the loudest manager. The difference is preparation and clear criteria.

Performance is not potential

This is the most common confusion. Someone can perform excellently in their current role and have no interest or ability for a bigger one; someone else with average performance, new in their role, can have a lot of potential. That is why they are assessed separately.

  • Performance: how well they do their current job. It comes from the performance review: goals and competencies.
  • Potential: the ability to take on roles of greater scope or complexity in the coming years.

How to define potential

If every manager means something different by potential, the review is useless. Agree on three or four criteria and describe what you observe for each. The most common:

  1. Learning agility: learns quickly in new situations and applies what they learn. Asks, tries, makes mistakes and adjusts.
  2. Aspiration: wants to grow and take on more responsibility. Without the desire, no potential helps.
  3. Influence: gets others to follow without relying on their title.
  4. Broader view: understands how their work affects other teams and the business.

Rate each criterion with concrete examples, not impressions. "Has potential" is not an argument; "last quarter they took over their manager’s project during their leave and closed it on time" is.

A simple three-level scale works well: potential to grow within their current role, for a next level in 1-2 years, or for two levels or more.

Before the session

  1. Close the performance review first. The talent review uses its results.
  2. Each manager proposes, for each person on their team, the potential level with two or three supporting examples.
  3. HR consolidates everything in a 9-box grid: performance on one axis, potential on the other.
  4. Prepare supporting data: time in role, career interests discussed, flight risk.
  5. Decide who attends: managers at the same level and their leader, with HR facilitating. Groups of 5 to 8 managers work best.

To place each person by performance and potential:

9-box grid (free template)

During the session

The goal is calibration: one manager’s "high potential" should mean the same as another’s. Some rules that help:

  • Start with the extremes: high-potential cases and low performers. That is where the most important decisions are.
  • Each placement is defended with examples. Other managers can ask and add what they saw.
  • Look for patterns: if a manager has their whole team in the top right, they are probably not differentiating.
  • Watch for biases: recency, similarity to yourself, whoever is most visible. Naming them at the start helps.
  • Write decisions down on the spot: who, what action, who owns it and by when.

The biases that show up most in these sessions:

Performance review mistakes and biases

The decisions that should come out

A talent review that ends without decisions was a conversation, not a review. For each group in the grid, something concrete:

  • High performance, high potential: accelerated development plan, stretch projects, visibility with leadership and a retention conversation. They are the first succession candidates.
  • High potential, average performance: understand what holds performance back (wrong role, little time in role, manager) and support them.
  • High performance, potential within their role: recognize and look after them. They are the backbone; not everyone has to want to move up.
  • Low performance: an improvement plan with clear goals and deadlines, or a conversation about whether the role is the right fit.

Succession decisions go straight into the succession plan, and every high-potential person should leave with an individual development plan.

To turn succession decisions into a plan:

Succession planning template

And each person’s development plan:

Individual development plan, with examples

Do you tell people which box they are in?

Most companies do not share the exact 9-box placement: labeling someone "low potential" rarely helps. What is shared is the outcome: development opportunities, new projects, the career conversation. People notice decisions more than labels.

How often

Once a year, after the performance review, is most common. Some companies run a shorter mid-year review only for key roles and successors.

How to read each box of the grid:

9-box grid and calibration

The full cycle, from goals to succession:

Performance management: the complete guide