Back to blog
·8 min read

How to run a performance review, step by step

In many companies the performance review is a form the manager fills in at year end, in a rush, remembering only what happened last month. The person gets a score they did not expect and nobody quite knows where it came from.

A review that works looks more like a year-long cycle. It starts with clear goals, has a checkpoint halfway and ends with a conversation that leaves a plan. It looks like this:

  1. 1

    Goals

    January to March

    Each person agrees 3 to 6 measurable goals with their manager.

  2. 2

    Mid-year

    June or July

    A short progress check to correct course in time.

  3. 3

    Self and manager

    November to January

    The person reviews themselves, then their manager does.

  4. 4

    Calibration

    1 or 2 weeks

    HR and managers check everyone is measured the same way.

  5. 5

    Feedback

    At the end

    Conversation, development plan and sign-off.

The cycle of a yearly performance review. Dates are an example: each company fits them to its own year.

1. Decide what you will measure

Almost every review measures two things: what the person achieved (goals) and how they worked (competencies). Before you start, decide how much each part weighs. A common starting point is 60% goals and 40% competencies. In sales roles results usually weigh more; in support roles, how the work is done.

  • Goals: 3 to 6 per person, each with how it is measured, the target and its weight.
  • Competencies: 4 to 6 for everyone, plus 1 or 2 only for people who lead teams.
  • Scale: 1 to 5, with a sentence explaining each number.
  • Final categories: for example "Exceeds", "Meets" and "Below", each with its minimum score.

If you have never run reviews, start simple: goals and the manager review. Calibration, peer feedback and the 9-box can come in the second year.

2. List your people and who reviews whom

You need a list with each person, their area, job title and manager. With that you know who reviews whom and can see results by area or by manager. Check the odd cases before you start: people with two managers, managers who changed mid-year and whoever sits at the top of the org chart, who also needs a reviewer.

People directory with area, job title and manager
A list with ID, area, job title and manager is all you need to know who reviews whom.

3. Set goals at the start of the year

Goals are agreed between the person and their manager in the first months. What matters is that they can be measured: "improve customer service" cannot be reviewed in December; "cut response time from 48 to 24 hours" can. The manager reviews them and approves them or sends them back with a comment.

Employee portal with goals, type, target and weight
Each goal with how it is measured, the target, the unit and its weight.

To go deeper, the guide on measurable goals has examples by area and how achievement is calculated.

4. Run a mid-year check-in

A short conversation in June or July prevents surprises. The person notes how each goal is going and the manager comments. If a goal no longer makes sense because the business changed, this is the time to adjust it, not December.

5. Self-review and manager review

At year end the person reviews themselves first: they enter their goal results, rate themselves on competencies and explain with examples. Then the manager reviews, with the self-review in view. The differences between the two are the most useful part of the final conversation.

Manager review with goal results and competencies
The manager reviews with the self-review and mid-year progress at hand. The final score is calculated for them.

If your company uses it, peer or team feedback comes in here too, always anonymous and grouped. It helps the manager see what they cannot see from above.

6. Calibrate before delivering

Some managers give their whole team a 5 and others never go above 3. If you deliver scores like that, people in different teams are measured with different rulers. Calibration is a meeting where HR and managers look at the score distribution, compare it with what is expected and adjust the cases that do not fit, always with a reason.

Calibration table with the score distribution and the 9-box
The distribution against the suggested curve and the performance and potential 9-box.

7. Feedback and development plan

The review ends in a conversation, not an email. The manager goes through the result, starts with what went well, talks about what is missing with examples and closes with 2 or 3 concrete actions with dates. The person signs off, or records their disagreement with a comment.

Employee result with score, goals and competencies
What the person sees at the end: their score, the detail and their development plan.

Common mistakes

  • Goals that cannot be measured, so the score depends on the manager’s mood.
  • Reviewing only the last two months. The mid-year check-in helps remember the rest.
  • Delivering scores without calibrating across managers.
  • Sending the result by email with no conversation.
  • Writing the development plan and never looking at it again.

For your first review, download the ready template in Excel and Word, with the score calculated:

Free performance review template (Excel and Word)

Goals, self-review, manager review, 9-box calibration and sign-off, in a portal where each person signs in without an account.

See SurvIQ Performance Review